This week we were greeted with the sad announcement from Jobs.co.nz that they had placed themselves into voluntary liquidation. Sad, from a few different angles really. A product that caused barely a ripple on the Australasian market dominance of SEEK ultimately failed in its’ bid to change the prescribed and traditional way of things. I’m a change agent, prone to occasional rebellion and a fan of disruption to effect positive change. The team at Jobs.co.nz operated under a similar mantra, bringing their cheeky, playful and irreverent style to a somewhat staid and static industry.
But it didn’t work.
The business launched with impressive flourish. There’s no doubting that jobs.co.nz is a stonkingly good URL to own, but the founders were somewhat naive to believe this might be strong enough alone to take on the might of SEEK and rapid emergence of TradeMe Jobs. Developing a pretty looking job board helped, and their working culture clearly succeeded in attracting talented web designers and developers to make something that actually worked.
But the truth behind job boards is that it’s mostly about who has the biggest marketing war chest to bring job seekers to your site. Without job seekers you are going to struggle to retain clients paying for ad posting. This is where TradeMe have been able to invest significant funds to build a marketing presence, an account management team and enviable SEO performance in order to successfully leverage off their “Kiwi” brand and get job seekers to apply for jobs there instead of on SEEK.
A futile ambition for the plucky but under-resourced Jobs team, they reacted by selling monthly subscriptions to job advertisers at cripplingly low rates, and attempted to create an impression of their site as a “socially-powered” job board, which basically entailed the marketing of the site, and the jobs on it, through the energetic, endearing and quirky personal brands created by the account management team within their own social media presence.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but this didn’t work either. I personally never received a worthwhile application to any of my ads on Jobs.co.nz, as much as I was longing for it to happen.
What Jobs excelled at was creating an aura of innovative and entrepreneurial spirit. A collective of bright, smart, engaging individuals who once even received an approach for acquisition from a large US job board. In many ways I think they probably believed their own hype a bit too much and when that offer was eventually withdrawn, the wind seemed to go from the sails.
The real shame is that 2013 has probably witnessed their best work. Making the correct decision to move away from job boards (which can never be truly “Social” no matter how hard you try and make them), they concentrated their creative energies into creating job infographics and job animations that begged for viral sharing across social media channels. This was great stuff and what I believed would define their long-term success.
Sadly, the legacy of debt and technology issues was too all-encompassing and smothering a burden for that creative and entrepreneurial spirit to continue to shine with the necessary fire. Ultimately they failed due to spending too long trying to be the wrong thing. When the lightbulb came on, the room was too dark to illuminate.
For me personally, I feel sadness because of what Jobs represented, and that this eventually failed. Jobs sought to take on the establishment, refuse to behave within pre-determined parameters, to re-define a stuttering industry and breath new life and innovation into the sector. That they failed is quite simply a huge victory for the prescribed, the traditional, the banal, and the old-fashioned ways of recruitment.
Many of our industry will probably be quite glad about that, and possibly even feel a sense of vindication, maybe even relief. But not me.
The previous employees of jobs.co.nz that I’ve spoken to so far seem in surprisingly good spirits about the whole thing. But then that’s their way, I suppose. They had a go, it didn’t work. At least they tried, and had a good time along the way.
Anyone interested in acquiring any of the assets of jobs.co.nz need simply visit their homepage to make contact with the liquidator.
Cheers Jobs. Tip of my hat to you. Good effort and no doubt we will see you in some re-incarnated form further down the track.
As a former employee of jobs.co.nz I am really proud of what we achieved in our time and very thankful to the founders for the amazing opportunity that led to many great relationships within our industry and a lot of personal and professional growth.
I’m also really grateful in the way they supported me in setting up my own business.
We worked hard and I think we did a great job of driving the use of social media for recruitment in New Zealand but you put it perfectly Jon, by the time the team got everything sorted it was just too late.
Huge hat tip to the jobs.co.nz team!!
I agree with your thoughts. I believe one need to be optimistic and calm when things go wrong! Its all about how much we learn while we work with an organization and how much we share the success of the team. good luck
As usual JR well written… in this case… ulogy.
Thanks for this excellent written article about our journey Jon, couldn’t of written it better myself. I’m totally stoked with where we got to this year and I could finally be truly proud (and believe in) what we were producing. I only hope our efforts weren’t wasted, but the way things seem to be turning in the market of social recruitment indicates it definitely won’t.
It was an awesome few years with an amazing team – looking forward to what’s next.
Thank goodness for new ideas. It would be a sad world without people willing to give it a try.
Great post Greg. In the USA, a failed business is seen as a badge of honour. Better to have fought and lost than never to have fought at all…as you said, good luck to all with a re-incarnation. By the way, what’s your Skype address Greg? I’d like to show you an innovative new products that I’m about to launch – recruitment training.com
Taxi for Mike?!
Sad to hear it hasn’t worked out but freaking good on them for giving it a blast! Putting your neck out and doing things differently is tough but you learn so much and sometimes even pull it off. We all need to encourage innovators because without them, the world is a much more boring place. Onwards and all the best with the new ventures!
Beautifully worded as always Mr Rice. I too liked the team at jobs and shared a very pleasant cold beer or two with Matt Walker and Kirsti Grant. Good luck to the whole team in their new ventures. The bigger picture for me is how the traditional job board market will have to change. Buying job board recruitment ad space is nearly dead in the United States with some of the biggest sources of hired candidates coming through http://www.indeed.com (they have 19k NZ jobs listed and 200k aussie ones) or http://www.simplyhired.com. It can only be a matter of time before they turn some of their marketing war chest to this part of the world as they make their money through advertising like google etc. As you said JR, the biggest marketing budget/brand wins the day. My prediction is that the traditional job boards will be gone within 2 years.