Last night was the SARAs, and the astute amongst you may have noticed that I no longer blog either my predictions or results, both for the SARAs and RCSA Awards. The reasons for this are nothing to do with the awards in themselves and more about my own ADHD. Simply put, I can’t do the same thing infinitum with the level of interest and motivation required to churn out a blog every Friday. Predicting awards has a shelf-life. It’s kind of unfortunate however, as last night’s were the most enjoyable I’ve been to for a long time. Maybe I just got lucky with who I chatted to, but there was a good vibe, and for the first time ever, no one tried to pick an argument with me based on some throwaway comment I’ve previously made in this very blog. There’s some industry news also which I should probably mention, with SEEK’s country Manager Rob Clark, not satisfied that Auckland’s weather is shite enough, has got the big job over in Melbourne. This means that Dave Swift, against everything his school reports predicted, has got the top job in NZ. I should also mention that this role is now “Managing Director” and not “Country Manager”. I know this because I caught Swifty puffing out his chest and practising his barbecue introduction in the mirror. Well done to them both, even if Melbourne is a toilet that won’t let you order a coffee without scanning a f*cking QR code.
As enjoyable as the night was, it did make me feel my age, which obviously, I rarely do. For me, reminders come in discreet moments. A police officer looking like a school kid. A teacher young enough to be your child. Someone giving up their seat for you. Being described as a GILF. It’s only then I realise that I’m perhaps no longer perceived as the flashing young blade I once believed myself to be. However, I’m not alone in thinking that in the most part, we all feel as if we’ve “still got it“, ignoring the fact that most of us never had it in the first place. This week I’ve been made to feel old in a brand new way. Thanks universe.
Obliviously bored with election chat, the world has decided to shift its attention to a more important topic; the actor who is to play the next James Bond. For some reason, Bond has always been an emotive topic. Not many out there don’t have a past favourite, and most have a semi-strong view on who should be next. The winner this time round, to the delight of all those young women who used to flick themselves off over vampires, is some pointy faced actor called Robert Pattinson. My use of adjectives prefacing his name gives you a clue on where this blog is heading.
Firstly, I’ve never watched anything with Robert Pattinson in, hence my need for those adjectives. When middle-aged men don’t know something or someone, we belittle it/them. Have you noticed that? Secondly, I think he’ll be a sh*t James Bond. It’s the fact that I make these two statements, complete with a nonsensical link between the two, that makes me objectively question my own judgement. And if I extrapolate this out to recruitment, then I have no choice but to worry.
Firstly, let’s stay on Bond. As much as I think Pattinson is too pointy and too pale to play Bond, the world mostly disagrees. Overall he is a popular choice. And I’m sure he will be wildly successful. Successful because people like me who have a different view on James Bond don’t go to the cinema any more. I’m not the target market, and we can all stop pretending all opinions are equal. To demonstrate how out of touch I am, I even thought Daniel Craig was an awful choice and refuse to watch him too. Just wait though, my rationale for my dislike for the Nik-Nak-headed muscleman is the ultimate in boomer ridiculousness: Daniel Craig can’t be James Bond because in real life, he can’t drive a manual car! That’s it. That’s my reason. And businesses are trusting me to make hiring decisions??! I have to recognise how silly this is, but I can’t help myself. I am clearly too old to pick a Bond, and that statement my friends, is ageism. Self-applied, but still ageism.
Ageism is a problem, but it’s not the same as other “isms”. Racism for example is fixed. If you are Māori at birth, you’ll be Māori forever more. You will not know what it is like to be pākehā. Being discriminated against because of age is different. If you’re not getting a job because you’re “too old”, you were once the youngster who benefitted from this prejudice. Hey, I’m not saying it’s right, but it is different. The weird situation we have is that hiring decisions are being made by people in their 40s and above, sometimes based on a shortlist presented by recruiters who are 40s and above, for roles which provide services and products to people considerably younger. And if I’m over the hill to have a view on the next James Bond, what makes me think I have such a great handle on what makes a good candidate today? Out of touch is out of touch.
Of course we can argue that good recruiters assess skills, potential AND experience. However we’re kidding ourselves if we claim to be totally objective. We carry sh*t loads of bias and prejudice. How can I tell anyone who will listen that modern music is rubbish and expect to be listened to when I say my judgement is timeless? Perhaps there is good reason that agency recruitment has always been seen as a young-persons game. We used to believe that this was because of the amount of energy and enthusiasm involved. Perhaps this is only part of it. Perhaps the mix of boomer decision makers, and young recruiters levelled the playing field? A heady mix of wisdom and youthful exuberance might actually be the secret sauce. Allowing middle-aged men to make all the hiring decisions would be as bad as letting me pick the next James Bond. And that would most definitely destroy the franchise.
Anyway, that killed some time as we wait for an actual government to form. Thank you to both SEEK and the James Bond Franchise for making me feel old. And for what it’s worth, George Lazenby was the best.
^SW

